logo new

button 100

  1. Emily Creely
  2. General Wetland Topics
  3. Friday, March 04 2016, 07:34 PM
Hi all -
While I think it's great that SWS engaged with other scientists and societies on critical issues such as biomass, I'm not sure I was so please by adding our name to a letter related opposing the use of forest biofuels for energy. This letter ignores a lot of the variables still in play for this issue and supporting a complete opposition to forest biomass is not prudent at this stage.

There is an awful lot of misinformation out there regarding carbon and biomass, and Dr. Booth has framed it as a binary discussion where in reality there is a great deal of nuance related to this matter.

I worked in rural development/watershed & forestry issues in the northern Sierra/southern Cascade region for four years and disagree with blanket opposition to forest biomass policies. In that part of the world, wetlands are 'meadows' and there may be benefits to wetland areas from forest thinning. Or not. It's still being studied and it's a fascinating area - to me the jury is still out.

I'm glad to see SWS engage on an issue with so many moving parts and policy implications, but I'd rather see SWS as a facilitating medium for such a complex issue rather than signing on.

Emily Creely
  Anchorage, AK, USA
Visit 
Comment
There are no comments made yet.


There are no replies made for this post yet.
However, you are not allowed to reply to this post.

Looking for a past discussion thread?

Visit the SWS Archived Forum

Recent Discussions

Replacement of Munsell and using Globe Soil Color Book
6226 Hits
2 Replies
Posted on Tuesday, January 12 2016, 04:39 PM
Munsell CAPSURE Device
265 Hits
3 Replies
Posted on Tuesday, June 18 2019, 04:12 PM
Writing about wetlands
263 Hits
0 Replies
Posted on Monday, June 10 2019, 12:41 AM
Women in Marine Science
249 Hits
0 Replies
Posted on Saturday, June 08 2019, 07:36 AM
Wetland restoration - edu webinars
309 Hits
0 Replies
Posted on Tuesday, June 04 2019, 08:36 PM

Categories

International
  1. 2 posts
  2. 0 subcategories
Asia
  1. 1 post
  2. 0 subcategories
South Central
  1. 1 post
  2. 0 subcategories
Pacific Northwest
  1. 2 posts
  2. 0 subcategories
Mid-Atlantic
  1. 3 posts
  2. 0 subcategories
Central
  1. 2 posts
  2. 0 subcategories
General Wetland Topics
  1. 60 posts
  2. 0 subcategories